For Sale Feb 9, 2026 Detached

34 Church Street

11 Beds
6 Baths
2500-3000 Sq Ft
Sale Price $839,000

Description

Welcome to 34 Church Street, Port Colborne, Ontario – a fully renovated and furnished legal 4-plex located on “The Island,” just steps from the revitalized Main Street district, canal-side parks, and scenic trail systems. This versatile property offers exceptional operational flexibility, licensed for both short-term rentals and long-term tenancies, or a hybrid approach to maximize returns.Set on a deep 52.8′ x 196′ lot, the residence features 11 bedrooms across multiple self-contained units, making it ideal for investors seeking strong cash flow or families looking for multi-generational living. A standout amenity is the 20′ x 40′ in-ground pool, adding lifestyle appeal and enhancing rental value. The property supports a range of investment strategies: repositioning the vacant 4-plex, house hacking by living in one unit while renting the others, offering furnished rentals for premium income, or exploring future redevelopment potential. With Port Colborne’s growth fueled by the nearby battery plant development and increasing demand for mid-term housing, this asset is well-positioned to deliver both immediate returns and long-term upside.

Property Details

Bedrooms: 11
Bathrooms: 6
Square Feet: 2500-3000
MLS Number: X12766958

Rooms

Living Room Main

4.11 x 8.46
Combined w/Dining

Kitchen Main

3.66 x 7.01

Bedroom Main

3.33 x 6.17
Walk-In Closet(s)

Kitchen Main

3.71 x 6.25

Primary Bedroom Second

3.53 x 6.27

Bedroom Second

3.53 x 3.71

Bedroom Second

3.35 x 3.71

Bedroom Second

2.29 x 3.66

Bedroom Second

3.66 x 4.27

Bedroom Second

3.66 x 4.27

Living Room Basement

3.35 x 5.26
Combined w/Kitchen

Bedroom Basement

3.4 x 3.53

Characteristics

Property

Status: Sale
Type: Detached
Style: 2-Storey
Size (sq ft): 2500-3000
Area: Niagara
Community: 877 - Main Street

Inside

Bedrooms: 11
Bathrooms: 6
Kitchens: 3
Rooms: 20
Air Conditioning: None

Building

Basement: Full
Heating: Forced Air
Water supply: Municipal
Exterior: Aluminum Siding
Exterior Features: Metal/Steel Siding

Parking

Garage: None
Parking Places: 6
Parking Total: 6

Fees

Taxes: 6449
Tax Year: 2025
Cable Included: Y
Tax Legal Description: LT 6 PL 772 CITY OF PORT COLBORNE

Utilities

Electricity: Y
Gas: Y
Cable: Y

Land

Fronting On: E
Frontage: 52.8
Lot Depth: 196.7
Lot Size Units: Feet
Water Source: Municipal
Pool: Inground
Sewer: Zoning
Parcel Number: 641370205
Cross Street: Weir Road, Main Street

Sale History

Date Event Price MLS Number
Feb 6, 2026 Listed $839,000 X12766958
Jul 28, 2014 Sold $223,000 X8924005
May 15, 2014 Listed $229,900 X8924005

Similar Properties

2607 – 181 Wynford Drive

$799,000
2+1 Bedrooms2 Bathrooms1000-1199 sq ft

Bright Gorgeously Renovated CORNER UNIT. ENLARGED Kitchen, Open Concept. This Suite Was Originally a 2+1. It has Been Elegantly Reimagined […]

View Details

#405 – 1801 O’connor Drive

$398,800
2 Bedrooms1 Bathrooms1000-1199 sq ft

Opportunity awaits in this boutique-style 2-bedroom, 1-bath condo offering parking, locker & an oversized private balcony – all in the […]

View Details

14 Catapillar Lane

$699,000
3 Bedrooms2 Bathrooms700-1100 sq ft

Welcome to one of the most private waterfront settings on the north shore of Berford Lake. Set on 2.1 acres […]

View Details

137 Willow Avenue

$2,169,000
4+1 Bedrooms4 Bathrooms1500-2000 sq ft

Bright, airy & thoughtfully designed, this 3-storey home offers the perfect blend of space, function, and lifestyle. Built in 2006 […]

View Details

146 5th A Street E

$449,999
2 Bedrooms2 Bathrooms700-1100 sq ft

Wake up to the best views of the Sydenham River in this truly one-of-a-kind semi-detached home, where nature and convenience […]

View Details
Playwright test automation by WrightTest
Scroll to Top